Greensboro, North Carolina

HomeNorth CarolinaGreensboro

Email Lawrence Egerton Lawrence Egerton on LinkedIn Lawrence Egerton on Twitter Lawrence Egerton on Facebook Lawrence Egerton on Avvo
Lawrence Egerton
Lawrence Egerton
Attorney • (800) 800-4529

DePuy hip implant replacement: One patient’s ordeal

Comments Off

After hip replacement surgery in February 2008, Kim Horbas was mobile and pain-free. But by the summer, her hip began to make a clicking sound when she walked.

“It got louder and louder, so you could hear me coming from a pretty far distance,” said Horbas, a 55-year-old woman from Champagne, Illinois. Just 10 months after her first surgery and recovery, Horbas underwent surgery again to have the hip device removed and a different one implanted.

That is the story of one person who had a DePuy hip replacement implant. Her ordeal will likely be experienced by thousands of other patients.

On August 26, 2010, the DePuy Orthopaedics company, a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson, issued a voluntary recall of two hip replacement systems. The hip implants are known as the ASR XL Acetabular System and DePuy ASR Hip Resurfacing System. About 93,000 of the devices have been implanted worldwide. The chances are that one out of eight of the implants will fail, requiring painful and expensive “revision” surgery.

Horbas went back to her doctor , who decided to take a look inside. He found metal staining the tissues, meaning the hip had been deteriorating inside. So, Horbas was facing surgery again and the ensuing rehab. “It was the same process all over again,” she said. “It’s pretty debilitating. You can’t move, you’re on a walker for four to six weeks, then you move on to a cane.”

To read the full story, see this article in the Illinois News-Gazette.

Horbas’s doctor, orthopedic surgeon Robert Bane, said he first began using the DePuy hip system in 2006, because its metal-on-metal construction was intended to make it last longer than the traditional device used in hip replacement surgery.

However, the rubbing of metal-on-metal releases microscopic metal particles. These microscopic particles disperse and accumulate in nearby parts of the body, where they can become toxic to tissue and possibly cause other problems. Bane stopped using the DePuy device when the first problem developed with a patient in late 2008. (This article explains further why the DePuy implant device fails.)

DePuy and Johnson & Johnson are offering compensation to patients injured by the implants. But the offer is limited.

Here is an excerpt from the DePuy recall statement:

“DePuy intends to cover reasonable and customary costs of testing and treatment if you need services, including revision surgery if it is necessary, associated with the recall of ASR … DePuy will then reimburse you for your reasonable out-of-pocket expenses.”

These statements are red flags. Who determines what is reasonable? The company that manufactured these faulty devices? And why are they offering “out-of-pocket” expenses only? What about the pain, mental anguish, scarring, or lost wages you might have suffered? Who will put a value on those damages?

The following articles can provide you with more information about:

Symptoms, health problems and possible damages

Documents releasing medical records (You should not sign them.)

Congressional hearings on Johnson & Johnson’s recall practices

Other patients’ cases and lawsuits

The severity of the health issues involved and DePuy’s limited offer of compensation mean you will need the counsel of an expert hip-replacement attorney. To be sure that you receive justice in your case, call us at Egerton Law – 336-273-0508 or 1-800-800-4LAW (4529). Or you can email me at le@egertonlaw.com. And you can contact us at our website. We will do what it takes to get you a fair and just settlement.

You will always speak to an attorney on your first call.